Source link : https://bq3anews.com/whats-peer-evaluation-the-position-nameless-professionals-play-in-scrutinizing-analysis-earlier-than-it-will-get-printed/
Reviewer 1: “This manuscript is a timely and important contribution to the field, with clear methodology and compelling results. I recommend publication with only minor revisions.”
Reviewer 2: “This manuscript is deeply flawed. The authors’ conclusions are not supported by data, and key literature is ignored. Major revisions are required before it can be considered.”
Those traces might be pulled from virtually any editorial choice letter on the earth of educational publishing, despatched from a magazine to a researcher. One evaluation praises the paintings, whilst any other sees not anything however issues. For students, this type of contradiction is not unusual. Reviewer 2, particularly, has grow to be one thing of a meme: an nameless determine incessantly blamed for delays, rejections or cryptic evaluations that appear to omit the purpose.
However the ones disagreements are a part of the peer-review procedure.
An international of memes – like this one shared on Reddit – has sprung up concerning the ridiculous comments equipped via a legendary Reviewer #2.
Reddit/r/medicalschool
As a medical nurse specialist, educator and student who opinions research in nursing and well being care and teaches others to take action significantly as neatly, I’ve observed how peer evaluation shapes now not simply what will get printed, however what in the long run influences follow.
Peer evaluation is the checkpoint the place…
—-
Author : bq3anews
Publish date : 2025-07-16 14:17:00
Copyright for syndicated content belongs to the linked Source.
—-
1 – 2 – 3 – 4 – 5 – 6 – 7 – 8